Bethel’s Bounty finds a new home for success
Room for growth in Library
The Bethel Park Community Foundation (BPCF) proved on Nov. 15 that it could take Bethel’s Bounty out of the municipality without erasing the event’s core identity.
Prizes continued to be plentiful while food and beverages from the community’s finest establishments flowed freely at the Library Volunteer Fire Hall. Folks had the usual fun and the BPCF raised an enormous sum of money to redistribute within the community.
“No, it’s not Bethel Park,” admitted Andy Amrhein, who is the vice president of the BPCF. “It’s just a stone’s throw across the border though.”
A change of scenery was necessary for Bethel’s Bounty because the event had “outgrown” its previous venues. What started decades ago at the community center swelled to the maximum of 300 guests allowed at the Crowne Plaza Suites-Pittsburgh South. And even then, the BPCF had to turn away guests.
“We had over 100 people on a wait list for tickets last year,” said Amrhein. “And, it’s hard to tell people, ‘No, you can’t come.'”
The Library Fire Hall, which is located at 6581 Library Road in neighboring South Park, seats upward of 450 people for receptions and events.
“So that was the big reason for moving here, but the place looks fabulous,” Amrhein said as he surveyed the room layout prior to the crowd’s arrival. “We’re very, very happy and excited to be here.”
Before the evening began at 5 p.m. Bethel’s Bounty had sold 79 more tickets than last year’s sold-out event. With the new set-up, ticket sales at the door could be accommodated.
“I like to have controlled growth,” Amrhein said. “Since it was our first year here, I didn’t know what to expect. I was nervous because I didn’t know how much space we would have for vendors and prizes and still have enough space.”
Because on-site parking was at a premium, the BPCF used school buses to shuttle guests to and from the satellite PRT park-n-ride lot. Plus, the fire hall serves as the home base for Cyd West Comfort Catering, which is one of the primary food vendors that annually attends Bethel’s Bounty.
While there were no new food vendors, Bethel’s Bounty relied upon what worked in the past. The regular eateries also included: Ma and Pop’s Country Kitchen, Metz Catering, Pasta Too, Rice Inn and Toss Pizza and Wings.
In addition to having a “full-fledged bar service” that fire halls provide, Reginald’s Coffee and Spoonwood Brewing Company served hot and cold beverages.
Bethel Bakery, Dairy Queen and Sarris Candies supplied desserts and sweet treats to finish off the feast.
“We went back to our original vendors and they’re all thrilled to death to be here and everybody loves them, too,” Amrhein added. “We actually could fit more but we wanted to wait and see how this worked out. We didn’t want it to be so crowded that people couldn’t move.”
Michelle Nickolas as well as Julie Koczko spoke enthusiastically for the vendors about the new venue. They were thrilled to be located nearer the action as the previous arrangement had the food stations arranged outside the banquet room, filled with round-table seating and raffle baskets.
“I love the new venue,” said Nickolas, who operates Toss with her husband, Eric. “As vendors, we are right next to the people inside versus having to come outside to eat. So it’s very open, but yet, I feel more connected to the community.”
Koczko, who owns Reginald’s Coffee, agreed the venue was “nice” and concurred regarding the connectivity. “You can see everybody. Before the vendors were separate from where people eat. So it’s nice to be able to kind of see what’s going on.”
After patrons had their appetites sated, the show of prizes and picking winners commenced. More than 60 gift baskets were donated by sponsors. The 50-50 raffle netted the winner more than $1,500 in cash. Some lucky patrons walked away with jewelry, weekend getaways, and even a 65-inch television.
A Library native, Amy Templeton was a multiple winner. She and her companion counted at least four or five gift baskets before packing up for home.
“I liked the new facility, and the event was a lot of fun,” she said. “I really enjoyed it. I live all the way in Monroeville. So it’s great to come out here for a good cause.”
Jodie Lee agreed. She attended the event with her daughter, Amanda, who is a second-grade teacher in North Carolina.
A Bethel Park native, Lee noted the BPCF also didn’t exist when she attended the high school
“While I don’t have anything to compare this too because this was our first time here (at Bethel’s Bounty), I think it’s wonderful,” Lee said. “I think it’s a great event and what the foundation does helps quite a bit within the community. It’s amazing.”
According to Amrhein, Bethel’s Bounty nets between $30,000 to $35,000 and so far this year the BPCF has donated over $100,000 in grants and scholarships.
“So we generate a big chunk of our income from this event,” he said.
With its new venue, the BPCF looks to continue to grow.
“Yes, this will be our permanent location,” he declared. “I think everything worked out very, very well. It’s been fabulous.”






















